Home forums Organizations Events Photos About Conservation Search Contact

FLY FISHING THE FINGER LAKES REGION IN NEW YORK - CAYUGA AND SENECA LAKE

Arrow Tackle Shops Arrow Lodging Arrow Photos Arrow Fly Patterns
Opportunities for fly fishing in the FInger Lakes region of New York State do not end with the closing of most tributaries on December 31 each year. As lake temperatures cool, you can depend on many salmonoids remaining inshore, offering the adventurous fly fisher a worthy challange. Also, keep in mind that select areas offer opportunities to take decent-sized northern pike on the fly from shore.

Warmwater discharges attract baitfish which in turn attracts hungry predators. Cayuga AES, formerly known as Milliken Station, is a coal fired plant on Cayuga Lake, just north of the town of Lansing, New York. It offers decent winter fishing for landlocked salmon and brown trout, as well as excellent fishing for northern pike. Salmonoid fishing has dropped off somewhat in recent years as high-powered strobe lights appear to be doing their job repelling baitfish from intake pipes. However, the warm water still attracts good numbers of fish, and the crownds of past seasons are no longer a factor. You should try your favorite baitfish patterns that imitate smelt of alewwives around the discharge and the point just south of it.

Fly Fishing Map Icon

CLICK FOR MAP

Hungry northern pike move into the warm bay as spawning time draws near. Fish run from three to 10 pounds--with good chances for larger ones. This area is shallow, typically less than eight feet deep, thus floating, intermediate and type II sinking lines will suffice. Clouser Minnows tied with inverted rabbit-strip wings as well as Barr's Pike fly work well. Bright colors like chartreuse are always a hot color. Be sure to use a heavy monofilament shock leader or nylon coated wire. Have pliers handy and be aware that some pike will tend to take flies deep.

Places to try for salmon and brown trout on Cayuga Lake include the entire southwest shoreline, as steep drop-offs close to shore provide places for fish to ambush bait. The boat launch at Taughannock State Park is bubbled to keep it ice free, thus offering access to the lake all winter long. Places shore bound anglers should check out include Dean's Cove and Taughannock State Park on the west shore, Cayuga AES, Myers point and Esty point on the east shore.

Lake trout are another fish available to the winter fly fisher. Seneca Lake is a great area for these. Many lakers seem to remaiin in relatively shallow water during the winter. A laker can turn up just about anywhere in Seneca, but major points and warmwater discharges are among the best places to begin your search. The decreasing population of smelt and alewife populations on Seneca Lake in conjunction with increased natural reproduction have resulted in hungry, opportunistic fish. These ravenous trout will consume just about any species they find including pike, bass, trout and panfish. Fly tying patterns can be all over the place.

Shore access on Seneca Lake is much better than on Cayuga. Areas to fish include Geneva at Sampson State Park, Severne point, and at Watkins glen. Boat launches are also scattered around the lake. Flies to carry are baitfish patterns as well as dark-colored Woolly Buggers. White, Grey, chartreuse and black in sizes 2 and 4 work well. Floating lines will work for fishing shallow points, but carrying some sinking lines with you is a very smart choice. Six- to 8-weight rods work well for this type of fishing. Choice your rod wisely taking into consideration wind and fly size.

If you are serious about fishing these areas with a fly rod in late January of February you would be smart to invest in detailed maps of the lakes which are available at local sport shops. They are well worth the money providing much more information. Seneca and Cayuga lakes almost never freeze over. Both are deep, massive bodies of water and must be respected. Wind can whip up these lakes quickly. Dress warmely, fish hard and approch this fishing with the same intensity as you would any stream fishing. You may end up counting down the days until the "off-season" each year.